Archive for August, 2008

mechanical turks

Wednesday, August 6th, 2008

So it seems that Amazon are expanding again & have launched their Mechanical Turk service. Which caught my eye largely because it reminded me of The_Turk, which is one of my all time favourite Wikipedia articles.

Amazon’s mechanical turk did grab my attention enough for me to take a look. Offering cash for tasks that can’t be automated in an online marketplace is an interesting idea. The sort of thing I might email to the recent graduates I know who complain that they can’t find a job. Except the remuneration for taking a HIT (Human Intelligence Task) is almost exclusively peanuts.

And you know the phrase – Only monkeys get out of bed for peanuts.

Which brings us to something that IS brilliant, The_Turk.

Which was a chess playing machine built in the late 18th century that claimed to be an automated chess machine but actually concealed a human chess master in a small cupboard. The Turk toured for the best part of a hundred years, and amongst other achievements, beat Bonaparte and was the subject of a Poe article.

A brilliant sense of imagination, wonder & showmanship at work in this story. Which reminds me of the Werner Herzog film Jeder für sich und Gott gegen alle (Every man for himself and God against them all)

So thank you amazon for reminding me of these. And interesting that you might name your new venture after an infamous hoax. I hope it’s irony I’m appreciating there.

worse is sometimes worse

Monday, August 4th, 2008

I don”t want to be informed about the webpages you were thinking of building. It can only ever disappoint me that you never got around to building them. The philosophy of worse is better, of getting some kind of working prototype out there is a completely valid one. Something is definitely better than nothing.

But if your something is less than a working prototype, then please don’t tell people about it who are not involved with developing it. If what you’ve come up with is a good idea, then this is especially true.

If you have an idea for a product, service that I would actually be interested in, then telling me that you have had the idea, but not the conviction to actually complete it is worse than me thinking that you never thought of it in the first place. All that you will do is waste your users time & raise their expectations only to have those expectations dashed, and potential users irritated.

If it’s broke, don’t ship it.